
CoarsetoFine Object Detection
by François Fleuret and Hichem Sahbi
Of all the techniques currently available, object recognition remains one of the most promising approaches to contentbased image retrieval. The advent of software able to detect and automatically recognise a wide range of objects in pictures would lead to a new generation of technologies based on highlevel semantics. Customers could, for instance, be provided with interactive online catalogues, or with improved search engine for TV network archives, which contain usually hundreds of thousands of hours of video.
In the classical approach, object detection is related to the broader field of pattern classification with statistical methods. Given a large number of examples, those techniques build classifiers that are able to label small patches of scenes as object or nonobject. Such a classifier is used on an entire scene, and at all possible scales, to achieve object detection. As it can be expected, putting aside issues related to learning, such a bruteforce approach necessarily has a very high computational cost. This is an important drawback, since the major areas using detection, such as realtime detection in video or indexing of large databases of pictures, require very low computation times in order to process several scenes per second.
INRIA’s IMEDIA research team is studying a family of algorithms which explicitly address the tradeoff between error rate and computational cost. We have developed several detectors based on the same idea of a hierarchical composition of classifiers, which reflects a hierarchical decomposition of the views of the object to be detected. Each one of these complex detectors is an adaptive sequence of tests: at each step, a classifier is chosen according to the responses received so far, and its own response is then computed.
This global approach has several important advantages. Firstly, it concentrates the computation on ambiguous areas; trivial areas are rejected early in the process, after a very small computation investment. The second advantage is that it dispatches the representation of the object being detected to a large number of learning machines, which can be very simple. For instance, this approach does not expect the classifiers to learn invariance to geometrical transformations of pictures, as such transformations are taken into account at the global level of the detector. The approach is also generic in respect of the type of classifiers. We have used either very simple edgecounting schemes or more sophisticated waveletbased support vector machines.
Given a large set of classifiers of varying cost and statistical power, we have studied how they can be combined in order to obtain the optimal average cost when processing a scene. This optimisation is based on a statistical model of the relation between the cost and the error rate of the individual classifiers. This leads to a constrained optimisation problem that can then be solved. As might be intuitively expected, both power and cost must grow, so the process begins with simple, almost trivial tests, and goes into details later. More precisely, the growth in complexity is exponential. The resulting strategy is able to reject trivial parts of the picture  like an empty sky or a wall  with very little computational cost (see Figure 1).


The figure on the left shows the result of facedetection. Each triangle indicates the location of a detected face, with an accurate pose estimation. The figure on the right gives a graphical representation of the computation intensity on the various parts of the pictures. Intensity is estimated by counting the number of times the algorithm takes into account the value of each pixel during the processing of the scene. White stands for a couple of such access, while the dark areas correspond to several hundreds of them. 
Future work will address the handling of large families of objects. Because it dispatches representations to a large number of classifiers, we expect the coarsetofine approach to enable control of the growth of both representation and computation when dealing with larger families of objects.
Please contact:
Hichem Sahbi, INRIA
Tel: +33 1 3963 5870
Email: Hichem.Sahbi@inria.fr
François Fleuret, INRIA
Tel: +33 1 3963 5583
Email: Francois.Fleuret@inria.fr
