Efficient Algorithms for Inverse Magnetic Field Problems
by Domenico Lahaye
The design of electromagnetic devices can be stated in mathematical terms as inverse magnetic field problems. Solving these hard optimisation problems efficiently is of prime industrial relevance. At CWI, research has started on a new class of algorithms for inverse problems based on the spacemapping algorithm. This algorithm exploits a multiscale representation of the space of design variables, in order to speed up the convergence of the optimisation process. Applications include the design of lowfrequency electromagnetic energy transducers.
In recent decades, the use of mathematical modelling and numerical techniques in the industrial design of electrical machines and transformers has gained popularity. Mathematical models for electromagnetic energy transducers are built starting from the Maxwell equations  a set of coupled partial
differential equations describing electric and magnetic fields. These equations are treated numerically by discretising them, for example, by the finite element method.
In industrial design practice, socalled inverse magnetic field problems arise frequently. These are optimisation problems in which one seeks a source distribution that produces an a priori specified magnetic field. These hard, nonlinear optimisation problems are mathematically intriguing due to their illposedness and nonunique solutions. Furthermore, finding solutions efficiently is critical, and is a key ingredient in the design of highgain electromagnetic energy transducers that are less susceptible to undesirable parasitic effects such as heat, noise and mechanical vibrations.
These inverse magnetic problems include design variables such as descriptions of the geometry of a device (eg the width of the air gap in an electrical machine), and external loading conditions in terms of applied currents and voltages (eg the current through the coils in an MRI scanning instrument). The evaluation of the function to be minimised (the cost function) for given values of the design variables requires a finite element simulation. These simulations form a computational bottleneck, especially in performing full threedimensional or transient modelling. Recently, the MAS2 research group at CWI started a research project with the aim of improving existing solution techniques for inverse magnetic field problems. The goal of this research project is to construct and apply new optimisation algorithms that reduce the required number of cost function evaluations. These algorithms are based on a recently introduced idea known as 'space mapping'.
Spacemapping algorithms exploit a multiscale representation of the search space in order to accelerate the convergence of the iterative optimisation process. While finescale models correspond to the previously mentioned finite element models, coarsescale models are simple analytic models for the device under consideration. Examples include magnetic equivalent circuits (equivalent to electrical circuits) or analytical expressions for the electromagnetic force and torque (such as the BiotSavart law). The coarsescale representation allows wellestablished rules of thumb to be incorporated in the optimisation process. The mapping from fine to coarse space is performed through a parameter extraction process. The spacemapping technique was introduced in the context of microwave engineering.


For currentcarrying coil and a permanent magnet, the first figure (left) shows the equipotential distribution computed by the finite element method. The second figure shows the triangular mesh used for the computation. 
In our project, we must solve quasistationary inverse magnetic field problems. The aims of the project are twofold. Firstly, we want to provide a theoretical framework for the spacemapping technique in order to gain insight into its convergence properties. We will do so by establishing links between the spacemapping technique and seemingly closely related defect correction techniques. For the latter, a sound mathematical theory exists. Secondly, we want to apply the spacemapping technique for the solution of quasistationary inverse magnetic field problems. A typical application that we have in mind is the design of a linear actuator to be used in a highaccuracy positioning system. This research effort is a collaboration between the MAS2 research group and the Electromechanics and Power Electronics (EPE) research group at the Eindhoven University of Technology, who will provide their expertise in modelling and design of electromagnetic devices and in the validation of design through experiments. The Dutch Ministry of Economic Affairs is funding the project through an intensive research program in electromagnetic power conversion technology (IOPEMVT).
We envisage two possible extensions of the current project. In the first of these, we plan to apply the space technique in the design of contactless energy transfer systems. In these systems, electrical energy is transmitted by magnetic induction, and electrical connections and physical contact are avoided. Recent applications of CETS have emerged, for example, in the transfer of energy to mobile platforms, in the interventionfree charging of household appliances and in medical scanning systems. In the second project extension, we plan to solve inverse problems in which magnetic and thermal aspcets are coupled. Solving these problems is an important step in the design of electromagnetic energy transformers that minimise heat loss.
Link:
http://www.cwi.nl/mas2
Please contact:
Domenico Lahaye, CWI
Tel: +31 20 592 4122
Email: Domenico.Lahayecwi.nl
